The history of cocktails is rich with fascinating, and sometimes bizarre, stories. From the elaborate creations of the Victorian era to the inventive experimentation of the mid-20th century, bartenders have consistently pushed the boundaries of flavor and presentation. But one particular tale stands out as exceptionally alarming: the “Arsenic & Old Lace” cocktail, a recipe from the 1930s that calls for a teaspoon of arsenic. Yes, you read that correctly. While seemingly a shocking anomaly, this recipe offers a chilling glimpse into a time before rigorous beverage safety standards were in place, a stark reminder of how dramatically consumer protection has evolved.
This recipe, originally published in 1930 by bartender Don Barr, has resurfaced and sparked considerable discussion, prompting questions about the lax regulations of the era and the surprising lack of knowledge surrounding the ingredients consumed. The story quickly gained notoriety after an article in *Food & Wine* () detailed the full recipe—including the arsenic—and has since been dissected by publications like *Wine Spectator*, further emphasizing the vast differences in ingredient sourcing and safety protocols.
The Players & The Pour
The “Arsenic & Old Lace” cocktail isn’t just a strange footnote in cocktail history; it’s a crucial element illustrating a significant gap in our understanding of food and beverage safety. The story began with Don Barr, a bartender working in Chicago during the 1930s. Barr himself apparently didn’t know the cocktail contained arsenic, a key detail that highlights the widespread lack of sophisticated analytical testing that existed at the time. Jancis Robinson, in her analysis of the story, suggests this was a relatively common practice – bartenders, and consumers alike, were largely unaware of the potential contaminants lurking in their drinks. This reflects a critical absence of quality control within the beverage industry, a situation that wouldn’t be rectified for decades to come.
Let’s delve into the recipe itself. The "Arsenic & Old Lace" cocktail, as originally presented, consisted of the following ingredients:
*
1 ounce Brandy:
A popular spirit of the time, brandy was widely consumed and often sourced from less regulated suppliers.
*
1 ounce Lime Juice:
Fresh lime juice was, and still is, a key component in many cocktails, providing acidity and balance.
*
1 teaspoon Arsenic:
This is, undeniably, the most alarming element. The precise form of arsenic used isn’t specified in the original recipe, further complicating the assessment of the potential danger. However, the addition of even a small amount of arsenic, a potent poison, presents a serious health risk.
*
1/2 ounce Absinthe:
Absinthe, a highly anise-flavored spirit, was gaining popularity in the 1930s, known for its potency and hallucinogenic effects. Combining it with arsenic would create an exceptionally dangerous concoction.
A Cautionary Tale
The “Arsenic & Old Lace” cocktail isn’t merely a historical curiosity; it’s a potent warning. It’s a powerful reminder of the risks associated with consuming alcoholic beverages and the absolute necessity of prioritizing safety. The recipe underscores the significant progress made in ensuring beverage quality and consumer protection. While the story is undoubtedly fascinating from a historical perspective, attempting to recreate it is undeniably dangerous and should be strictly avoided. The potential consequences of consuming arsenic, even in small doses, are severe, ranging from gastrointestinal distress to organ damage and, ultimately, death.
The recipe’s existence speaks volumes about the regulatory landscape of the early 20th century. There were no mandatory ingredient testing protocols for alcoholic beverages. Producers weren’t required to verify the purity of their products, and consumers had no way of knowing if their drinks contained harmful contaminants.
Last Call:
The “Arsenic & Old Lace” cocktail serves as a vital reminder to always prioritize safety when indulging in alcoholic drinks, and to appreciate the significant advancements made in ensuring beverage quality and consumer protection. It’s a testament to the importance of robust regulatory oversight and rigorous testing procedures. Don’t drink arsenic, and tell your friends. The story highlights not just a bizarre cocktail recipe, but a critical turning point in the history of food safety – a period where a lack of knowledge and regulation nearly resulted in a devastating outcome.
Source: https://www.foodandwine.com/arsenic-and-old-lace-cocktail-recipe-11906808
