The recent death of Renee Good during an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) crackdown in Minneapolis has become a focal point for conservative media, fueling a troubling trend: the deliberate framing of social movement participants as disruptive and, fundamentally, ‘at fault.’ While the initial conversation centered around self-defense, the narrative quickly evolved, with figures like Vice President JD Vance labeling Good as contributing to her own ‘tragedy.’
Origins of the Framing: Shifting the Target
This tactic isn’t entirely new to U.S. political discourse. Historically, protests have frequently been cast as the actions of ‘extremists’ or ‘violent’ individuals. However, the current focus is markedly different. Conservative media outlets are now specifically targeting middle-class, suburban, white women who engage in social movements, particularly those identified as ‘wine moms’ – a descriptor increasingly used to paint these participants as overly emotional and disruptive.
Experts Analyze the Strategy
Communications expert Shana MacDonald, from the University of Waterloo, describes this approach as a deliberate attempt to create a cultural enemy. “These ‘wine moms’ are typically middle-class, suburban, white, and have money for leisure,” she explains. “It’s a strategic move to polarize the public by presenting a clearly defined ‘other.’”
CBC News senior writer Natalie Stechyson has expressed significant concern, stating, “This shift in language is ‘really, really troubling.’ It’s crucial to recognize how language is evolving and who is being positioned as the ‘enemy.’”
Consequences and Implications
The potential ramifications of this framing are significant. The strategy risks exacerbating political polarization, eroding trust in institutions, and fundamentally damaging public discourse. By casting individuals involved in social movements as inherently problematic, the narrative undermines legitimate grievances and creates barriers to productive conversation.
The Players Involved
Key figures amplifying this narrative include Fox News, conservative media outlets, columnist David Marcus, President Donald Trump, Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem, and Vice President JD Vance.
What This Means for Consumers
Consumers of news media should be particularly vigilant regarding the language used to describe social movements. The ‘wine mom’ framing highlights the deliberate manipulation of public perception and the need to critically assess the sources of information.
Pros and Cons
*
Pros:
Increased awareness of strategic framing techniques. *
Cons:
Risk of perpetuating harmful stereotypes and undermining legitimate social movements.*
